Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe — cheaper alternatives

Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle: released in 2023, woody, green and patchouli, about 5h on skin, projection 5/10, sillage 3/10. The alternatives below are matched to that profile.

What's a good Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe?

The closest Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe we found is Hermès Eau de Gentiane Blanche — 78% match, about $90 (estimate) versus about $300 for a 100 ml bottle.

The five closest scent matches — the best Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupes we found, ranked by opening & dry-down similarity:

How the 5 picks compare on match, price and performance. Prices are estimates for a 100 ml bottle, not live retailer prices.
#AlternativeScent matchEst. price (100 ml)Longevity vs Jo Malone London Melancholy ThistleProjection
1Hermès Eau de Gentiane Blanche78%about $90 (−70%)5h vs 5h6/10
2Carthusia Essence of the Park73%about $100 (−67%)5h vs 5h7/10
3Miller Harris L'Air de Rien68%about $175 (−42%)7h vs 5h6/10
4Atelier des Ors Riviera Drive63%about $135 (−55%)4h vs 5h7/10
5Mutis Nueva Granada Melao82%about $80 (−73%)5h vs 5h8/10
  1. Hermès Eau de Gentiane Blanche — 78% scent match

    Offers a crisp, rooty, and slightly bitter green profile that aligns with the botanical, thistle-forward aesthetic of the reference.

    It lasts about 5h against 5h and carries 1,553 community ratings.

  2. Carthusia Essence of the Park — 73% scent match

    Captures a lush, garden-like green freshness that feels reminiscent of the damp, woody, and herbal nuances in Melancholy Thistle.

    It shares its herbal and yellow floral accords with Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle, lasts about 5h against 5h and carries 242 community ratings.

  3. Miller Harris L'Air de Rien — 68% scent match

    Leans into a similar earthy, lived-in muskiness that complements the patchouli and woodsy base notes of the reference.

    It shares its woody and patchouli accords with Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle, lasts about 7h against 5h and carries 1,145 community ratings.

  4. Atelier des Ors Riviera Drive — 63% scent match

    Provides a bright, aromatic herbal opening that shares a similar spirit with the fresh, ozonic qualities of the reference.

    It shares its woody and herbal accords with Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle, lasts about 4h against 5h and carries 366 community ratings.

  5. Mutis Nueva Granada Melao — 82% scent match

    Shares a similar green, herbal character that evokes the wild, earthy atmosphere found in Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle.

    It shares its warm spicy accords with Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle, lasts about 5h against 5h and carries 12 community ratings.

Which Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe is cheapest?

Mutis Nueva Granada Melao, at about $80 for 100 ml (estimate) — around 75% less than Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle.

Which Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe lasts longest?

Miller Harris L'Air de Rien, at about 7h on skin, against about 5h for Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle.

Which Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe is closest to the original?

Mutis Nueva Granada Melao, at 82% overall scent match across the opening and the dry-down.

How much does a Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe save?

At 4 sprays a day — about 146 ml a year — Hermès Eau de Gentiane Blanche saves you about $305 a year against Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle. Both priced at 100 ml; prices are estimates.

Across 2,358 originals, the median designer bottle is $120 and its closest match $30 — the Dupe Report 2026.

Will a Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle dupe last a full day?

On an 8-hour day, none of the 5 last a full 8 hours. Miller Harris L'Air de Rien comes closest at 6.6h, so it needs one re-spray to cover the day.

Jo Malone London Melancholy Thistle notes, performance and price

Related dupe lists

Lists and reports

AltScent is also free on the App Store and Google Play.

Updated 2026-11-10.