Lush Butterball dupe — cheaper alternatives

Lush Butterball: released in 2018, sweet, powdery and chocolate, about 4h on skin, projection 5/10, sillage 3/10. The alternatives below are matched to that profile.

What's a good Lush Butterball dupe?

The closest Lush Butterball dupe we found is ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk — 88% match, about $25 (estimate) versus about $25 for a 100 ml bottle.

The five closest scent matches — the best Lush Butterball dupes we found, ranked by opening & dry-down similarity:

How the 5 picks compare on match, price and performance. Prices are estimates for a 100 ml bottle, not live retailer prices.
#AlternativeScent matchEst. price (100 ml)Longevity vs Lush ButterballProjection
1ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk88%about $256h vs 4h7/10
2ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk Eau de Parfum86%about $20 (−20%)5h vs 4h6/10
3ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk Marshmallow83%about $35 (+40%)5h vs 4h8/10
4Pierre Guillaume Paris Musc Maori 0482%about $65 (+160%)5h vs 4h6/10
5Kuumba Made Black Coconut78%about $10 (4 ml)5h vs 4h3/10
  1. ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk — 88% scent match

    Shares the same cozy, chocolate-forward sweetness found in Lush Butterball, offering a warm and comforting gourmand experience at a very accessible price point.

    It shares its vanilla, warm spicy and chocolate accords with Lush Butterball, lasts about 6h against 4h and carries 6,499 community ratings.

  2. ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk Eau de Parfum — 86% scent match

    Provides a slightly more refined, sprayable version of the chocolate and musk profile that makes Lush Butterball so popular for daily wear.

    It shares its vanilla, warm spicy and chocolate accords with Lush Butterball, lasts about 5h against 4h and carries 3,991 community ratings.

  3. ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk Marshmallow — 83% scent match

    Builds on the familiar chocolate and musk foundation of the original, adding a fluffy sweetness that mirrors the comforting vibe of Lush Butterball.

    It shares its sweet, powdery and vanilla accords with Lush Butterball, lasts about 5h against 4h and carries 427 community ratings.

  4. Pierre Guillaume Paris Musc Maori 04 — 82% scent match

    Evokes the soft, powdery chocolate and musk character of Lush Butterball with a sophisticated, airy quality that feels very similar on the skin.

    It shares its cacao, vanilla and warm spicy accords with Lush Butterball, lasts about 5h against 4h and carries 1,198 community ratings.

  5. Kuumba Made Black Coconut — 78% scent match

    While leaning more into coconut, it captures the same creamy, skin-scent muskiness that defines the base of Lush Butterball.

    It shares its sweet and vanilla accords with Lush Butterball, lasts about 5h against 4h and carries 147 community ratings.

Which Lush Butterball dupe is cheapest?

ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk Eau de Parfum, at about $20 for 100 ml (estimate) — around 20% less than Lush Butterball.

Which Lush Butterball dupe lasts longest?

ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk, at about 6h on skin, against about 4h for Lush Butterball.

Which Lush Butterball dupe is closest to the original?

ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk, at 88% overall scent match across the opening and the dry-down.

How much does a Lush Butterball dupe save?

At 4 sprays a day — about 146 ml a year — ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk saves you about $5 a year against Lush Butterball. Both priced at 100 ml; prices are estimates.

Across 2,358 originals, the median designer bottle is $120 and its closest match $30 — the Dupe Report 2026.

Will a Lush Butterball dupe last a full day?

On an 8-hour day, none of the 5 last a full 8 hours. ALREHAB PERFUMES Choco Musk comes closest at 5.8h, so it needs one re-spray to cover the day.

Lush Butterball notes, performance and price

Related dupe lists

Lists and reports

AltScent is also free on the App Store and Google Play.

Updated 2026-11-10.