Commodity Leather is discontinued — the closest scent matches you can still buy

Commodity Leather, released in 2017, is discontinued and no longer in production. The closest scent matches you can still buy are below.

Commodity Leather: amber, woody and aromatic, about 5h on skin, projection 7/10, sillage 4/10. The alternatives below are matched to that profile.

What can I wear instead of Commodity Leather?

The five closest scent matches — the closest replacements for Commodity Leather we found, ranked by opening & dry-down similarity, with the ones still in production first:

  1. Shay & Blue London Blacks Club Leather — 81% scent match

    Focuses on a rich, authentic leather accord that resonates with the primary leather note found in the Commodity fragrance.

    It shares its woody, leather and amber accords with Commodity Leather, opens on Leather too, lasts about 6h against 5h and carries 157 community ratings.

  2. Al Wataniah Oudh Al Aswad — 80% scent match

    Provides a dense, woody, and leathery depth that mirrors the animalic and balsamic qualities present in the original composition.

    It shares its woody, warm spicy and amber accords with Commodity Leather, lasts about 7h against 5h and carries 4 community ratings.

  3. Hawthorne Studded Smoke — 75% scent match

    Evokes a similar blend of smoky and leathery accords, providing a modern, masculine scent profile reminiscent of the Commodity original.

    It shares its woody, fresh spicy and warm spicy accords with Commodity Leather, lasts about 10h against 5h and carries 9 community ratings.

  4. John Varvatos Dark Rebel Rider — 89% scent match — discontinued

    Captures the rugged, leathery essence of Commodity Leather with a similarly dark, resinous profile that feels both sophisticated and edgy.

    It shares its woody, amber and leather accords with Commodity Leather, lasts about 5h against 5h and carries 1,025 community ratings. It is listed as discontinued, so availability varies.

  5. John Varvatos Dark Rebel — 84% scent match — discontinued

    Shares the deep, tobacco-infused leather character found in Commodity Leather, offering a similarly moody and masculine aromatic experience.

    It shares its woody, leather and aromatic accords with Commodity Leather, lasts about 5h against 5h and carries 1,963 community ratings. It is listed as discontinued, so availability varies.

Which Commodity Leather dupe is cheapest?

Al Wataniah Oudh Al Aswad, at about $45 for 100 ml (estimate) — around 70% less than Commodity Leather.

Which Commodity Leather dupe lasts longest?

Hawthorne Studded Smoke, at about 10h on skin, against about 5h for Commodity Leather.

Which Commodity Leather dupe is closest to the original?

John Varvatos Dark Rebel Rider, at 89% overall scent match across the opening and the dry-down.

How much does a Commodity Leather dupe save?

At 4 sprays a day — about 146 ml a year — Shay & Blue London Blacks Club Leather saves you about $110 a year against Commodity Leather. Both priced at 100 ml; prices are estimates.

Across 2,358 originals, the median designer bottle is $120 and its closest match $30 — the Dupe Report 2026.

Will a Commodity Leather dupe last a full day?

On an 8-hour day, these cover it: Hawthorne Studded Smoke (9.8h) — 1 of 5.

Commodity Leather notes, performance and price

Related dupe lists

Lists and reports

AltScent is also free on the App Store and Google Play.

Updated 2026-11-08.