Mancera Black to Black scores 88% against Montale Black Aoud overall — scored twice, once on the opening and once on the dry-down, because a scent rarely stays still on skin.
The match improves as it wears. Mancera Black to Black opens 85% like Montale Black Aoud and reaches 90% by the dry-down, so give it an hour before judging it — the first spray is the least similar part of this comparison.
Both are built on rose, oud, patchouli and woody. Montale Black Aoud adds musky and citrus that Mancera Black to Black does not. Mancera Black to Black brings leather and animalic of its own.
| Montale Black Aoud | Mancera Black to Black | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (estimate) | about $140 | about $85 |
| Longevity | 9h | 9h |
| Projection | 10/10 | 9/10 |
| Sillage | 8/10 | 7/10 |
| Released | 2006 | 2015 |
| Main accords | rose, oud and patchouli | warm spicy, rose and oud |
On the estimates above, Mancera Black to Black sits about $55 under Montale Black Aoud — roughly 39% less. Both figures are typical market prices rather than one shop's, so treat the gap as a direction rather than a quote.
Shares the same DNA as the reference, delivering a potent, dark rose and oud combination that feels like a more modern evolution.
Scores are estimates built from note structure and community consensus, not laboratory measurements, and noses genuinely differ — treat a high match as a strong lead rather than a promise. AltScent is independent and is not affiliated with, authorized by or endorsed by any brand shown.
All alternatives to Montale Black Aoud
What Mancera Black to Black is a dupe of
Montale Black Aoud notes, performance and price · Mancera Black to Black notes, performance and price
Find a scent-matched dupe for any designer perfume. Popular searches: